Perfection, Once Again


It looks like I came back from New York just in time for Daring Bakers! I need to do a report on my favorite dessert spots in the Big Apple, but of course how could I not participate in this month’s baking extravaganza, especially when it involves Dorie and a cake dear to my heart!

I made this cake before for my blog birthday, and I’m more than pleased to have a reason to make it again. It is a wonderful recipe that turns out a gorgeous cake with snowy good looks, elegant crumb, and pert, clean flavor. I’m afraid I didn’t have time to get creative with the flavors as I’m sure many other Daring Bakers did; freshly home from my trip, I was just glad there was a jar of raspberry jam in the refrigerator and flour in the cupboard!


Never mind jet-lag woes: the cake is a snap to throw together even in a zombie-like post-trip trance. The cake is luxurious; moist and flavorful and yet firm enough to hold its form and cut cleanly. I was particularly enamoured with the pairing of lemon and raspberry flavors the first time I made it, so I was happy to repeat the combination – besides, the raspberry jam does look so pretty next to the pristine white of the cake. It also gives the cake a light freshness, even with four layers.

Dorie’s buttercream recipe is also a winner to me; fast, simple, and nearly foolproof. No need to muck about with cooking sugar or whipping egg whites, and I find its buttery smoothness complements the cake as well. If you’re looking for tips on frosting cakes, be sure to read my post on working with buttercream.

Thanks to Morven for reminding me of how much I adore this cake. And now, I should mention why I’m also so happy that a Dorie recipe got picked for this month – because I met up with Dorie in New York! Of course, I asked her if she knew about the Daring Bakers, and her immediate response was, "They’re doing that Perfect Party Cake, the one where the cake doesn’t rise!" Apparently she found that many people doing the recipe were using self-rising cake flour, which paradoxically led to collapsing cake layers that ended up flatter than intended. Note to all who attempt this recipe: DON"T use self-rising cake flour, and be sure you beat the butter and sugar together thoroughly, as well as the final combined batter, to properly aerate. I’ve never had a problem with having the cake layers rise – then again, when the cake is four layers, you don’t need to worry too much about your layers being too thin! No worries Dorie, I’m a lifelong fan of this cake!


Dorie is basically the most awesome person ever – sweet, funny, ready to take on any pastry (we ate our way through several plates at Payard), and with the best taste in accessories! AND a Daring Baker fan! She was so excited to know that so many people in the blogosphere were being inspired to bake – and here’s the proof!


My present to all you Daring Bakers out there from me and Dorie: Go Daring Bakers!

I’m looking forward to next month’s recipe!

Perfect Party Cake

adapted from Dorie Greenspan’s Baking: From My Home to Yours

makes 12 to 14 servings


9 oz cake flour

1 tablespoon baking powder

1/2 teaspoon salt

10 3/4 fl. oz. buttermilk

4 large egg whites

10 1/2 oz sugar

2 teaspoons grated lemon zest

4 oz unsalted butter, room temperature

1/2 teaspoon lemon extract


7 oz sugar

4 large egg whites

12 oz unsalted butter, room temperature, cut into 1-in pieces

2 1/4 fl. oz. fresh lemon juice

1 teaspoon vanilla extract

For finishing

2/3 cup seedless raspberry preserves

1 1/2 cups sweetened shredded coconut

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Spray or butter two 9" x 2" round cake pans. Line the bottom of each cake pan with a buttered parchment circle.

For the cake: Sift together the cake flour, baking powder, and salt.

Whisk the buttermilk and egg whites together in a separate bowl.

Combine the sugar and lemon zest in a stand mixer bowl and rub together with your fingers until the sugar is moist and smells like the lemon.

Add the butter to the mixer bowl and beat together with the sugar for 3 minutes on medium speed until the mixture is fluffy and light.

Add in the vanilla extract.

Add in the flour and buttermilk mixtures in alternating additions, starting and ending with the flour mixtures. Be sure each addition is fully incorporated before adding the next.

When everything is added beat the batter for an additional 2 minutes.

Divide the batter between the two pans and bake for 30 minutes in the oven or until the tops are set and springy, and a cake tester inserted into the centers come out clean.

Transfer the pans to wire racks and let cool for a few minutes, then flip and unmold the cakes (run a knife around the sides of the cakes if necessary). Peel the parchment off and flip the cakes back over right side up on the wire racks to finish cooling.

The fully cooled cake layers can be wrapped in plastic and kept overnight or frozen for up to 2 months.

For the buttercream: Combine the sugar and egg whites in a medium heatproof bowl and place over a pan of simmering water.

Whisk the sugar mixture constantly over heat until the sugar is dissolved and the mixture looks smooth and shiny, about 3 minutes.

Remove mixture from heat and pour into a stand mixer bowl. Whisk on medium speed for about 5 minutes until the mixture has cooled.

Switch to the paddle attachment and with the speed on low, add the butter a few pieces at a time, beating until smooth.

When all the butter has been added, beat the buttercream on medium-high speed for about 6-10 minutes until it is very thick and smooth.

Add in the lemon juice and beat until combined. Add in the vanilla.

The buttercream is ready to be used. Place a piece of plastic wrap against the surface until you are ready to use it to prevent it from drying out.

To assemble the cake: Using a sharp serrated knife, slice each cake layer horizontally in half – see this post for tips on cutting cake layers.

Stir the raspberry preserves until it is loose and spreadable.

Place a layer on a cardboard cake round, cut side up. Spread about a third of the raspberry preserves on the cake layer.

Spread a layer of buttercream on top of the preserves. Top with a second cake layer. I found that if you have problems with this, you can spread the buttercream on a second cake layer and flip it over onto the preserve-covered layer – but you have to be very careful doing this or you’ll break your cake layer!

Spread preserves and buttercream on the second cake layer as you did with the first. Top with a third cake layer.

Spread preserves and buttercream on the third cake layer as you did with the second. Top with the last cake layer, cut side down.

Use the rest of the buttercream to frost the sides and top of the cake.

Pr ess the coconut over the sides and top of the cake.

The cake is best served a couple of hours after it is assembled to let the flavors develop. You can refrigerate it for up to 2 days, but be sure it is well covered or the cake will dry out. You should also let the cake come to room temperature before you serve it as it does not taste as good cold.


Tagged with: + + +

Bite This!


  1. 1


    Wow your cake looks stunning. I love the colour contrast between the white cake and the vibrant red jam. I’m impressed you actually got to meet Dorie.

  2. 2


    Such beautifully perfect slices! I agree that the jam is lovely against the white cake. And what a yummy cake! Thanks for sharing your visit/photo with Dorie. How cool is that?

  3. 3


    Thanks for the picture! Your cake looks wonderful and ever so PERFECT!!! Very well done, as usual…



  4. 5


    Hi Anita!
    I just found your blog through someone else’s blog that left a comment on mine. You know how these things work.
    Anyhow, I was so impressed that I had to come see the rest of it. Every post is so beautifully done and the photographs are stunning.
    Well done!

  5. 6


    Love the look of your cake! And great shout-out! I guess now we know how Dorie found out what we were baking this month :-)

  6. 7


    Incredible meeting, what fun for you! That is absolutely fantastic! Your cake looks especially perfectly tasty and good! I do love the layers and the color contract you got. Beautiful!

  7. 9


    your photos are absolutely lovely! I find it hard to believe that cake was made under the fog of jet-lag, it is simply too perfect!! and by the by, raspberry jam and lemon sound delicious – and now I want a piece!

  8. 16


    Wow! Your cake is this perfect little square of yumminess AND you got to hang out and eat pastries with Dorie! How cool!!!

  9. 17


    Perfection as usual… What a great baker you are.
    You work so well, I wish I could have seen a picture of the complete cake.

  10. 18

    dreamsicle says

    Welcome back! Can’t believe you started baking soon after you got back – go gal! The cake looks cute and it’s just so “you”.

    And meeting Dorie too? You must have been thrilled! I can’t wait to hear more about your travels in NYC. 😀

  11. 19


    Hi Anita,

    I like the way you cut and present your cake. BTW, I’m looking forward to read your first book. :)


  12. 23


    Oh! Make me swoon, Anita! You put us all to shame with those incredible pictures and that cake! You’re an inspiration. And what a great photo with Dorie … makes my heart happy!

  13. 28


    WOW, you know Dorie!?!? That is so cool! Lucky gal.
    I love the way you cut your cakes into those high squares, very very elegant!!!

  14. 29


    I have been a big fan of your blog for quite some time and I am so sorry it has taken me this long to comment. A few things really, 1. the cake looks gorgeous…no surprise
    2. I am insanely jealous that you had the opportunity to meet up with Dorie how cool is that!?
    3. Thank you for your blog, it is fun, informative and inspiring. Thanks again :)


  15. 30


    I love the way you sliced your cake into towering squares! Lucky you to have met Dorie herself!

  16. 31


    I was so glad that we could get together for tea and cookies during your whirl through New York — it was a pleasure to have time to chat. And as always, your baking is lovely. You are so very talented.

  17. 34


    It’s so cool you met up with Dorie! Your cake looks absolutely perfect! I had a problem with the cake rising even when I used cake flour, hmm… maybe I should beat it a little more next time. But it’s okay because I’m also in love with this cake and Dorie’s buttercream.

  18. 35


    well done. So nicely cut up. I will say that it did cut well this cake, but i didn’t even attempt to try and slice it like you did. My famioly were too hungry!

  19. 38



    Working my way through all Daring Bakers to see all those wonderful cakes and wanted to say how very stylish yours look – you are a true artist!

    I also very much agree that desserts should come first.


  20. 40


    I think your blog is the first place I had ever seen this cake made before. And I remember it being beautiful then and even more beautiful now. Your layers are so perfect. I could never cut slices like that.

  21. 41


    Your cake looks perfect. I love the shape of the pieces and the contrast of the cake and the filling.

  22. 45


    You’re right: perfection indeed!! I think people were worried about their layers being thin but that is because there is much to be put in the middle and if they were 2 inches high each, that would be a tower of a cake!! You’re right about spotting the towels you sent me! I saved them especially for the challenge! Thank you again dear sweet friend! Love that last picture with Dorie!

  23. 47


    Absolutely stunning cake! Such white and even layers, wow!
    Such fun to read you met with Dorie.
    Sidenote: I *did* use cake flour, albeit European, and followed the recipe to a t. Why my cakes stayed flat? No idea..

  24. 48


    How cool is that! (Though who sprung the leak and told her about it before hand!)
    Your cake looks amazing!

  25. 49


    Those slices are PERFECT, as usual with everything you do. How do you do it? And can you teach me? Pretty please?

  26. 51


    Yay! Anita!! Your cake *is* perfect and you are a *perfect* baker! That is a totally awesome surprise to have your pic with Dorie. Absolutely beautiful, just like you :) xxoo

  27. 53


    Anita, your cake looks as if it came from a bakery! The pictures are amazing, too.

    It must have been great to meet Dorie! I, too, am now a lifelong fan of this cake.

  28. 54


    Nice job with the cake!
    I met Dorie when she did a demo in Rochester for Paris Sweets. I also found her to be very cool and nice. Which reminds me … I’ve got to actually TRY some of those recipes!

  29. 55


    How fun to meet Dorie!!! Your cake is awesome too. I love it when life is good.

    Looking forward to hearing about the NYC trip, Amy

  30. 57

    Maria says

    I am glad you made the cake again, it is gorgeous! Sounds like NY was a fun trip. I am jealous you had dessert with Dorie. Thanks for sharing your stories. I can’t wait to hear more!

  31. 62


    Oh that’s so sweet of Dorie!! I didn’t have much of a problem with my cake rising, using cake flour… And yours look lovely with the confetti on top of those perfect squares!

  32. 65


    Your cake is utterly beautiful. AND you got to meet Dorie. So awesome that she knows about the DBs!

  33. 67


    That is so cool that you and Dorie are cheering the DBs on! The cake really is a joy…as long as you take the time to beat it as much as specified. Your is truly beautiful and elegant looking, too.

  34. 68


    That’s so cool! It’s cool to know that people who’s recipes we bake are cheering us on!

    Your cake looks divine! Now I want to make it all over again.

  35. 70


    THAT IS AWESOME!!! What a fabulous post, surprise and your beautiful job on the cake- it looks fantastic!

  36. 71


    Beautiful your cake, and its cut¡¡

    And thank for your present, this picture with dorie is fantastic¡¡


  37. 72


    LOL- I love that picture of you and Dorie holding up the Daring Bakers sign…that is priceless.
    A beautiful cake you have here Anita.

  38. 75


    a gorgeous brick of cake that size needs a more appropriate utensil, perhaps a pitchfork or…my hands. it’s just lovely! :)

  39. 76


    Anita, your cake looks incredible I love the little squares and what a treat you and Dorie together. Thanks!

  40. 77


    I remember your cake from last year, and you’ve done it beautiful this year!! How fun to meet Dorie!

  41. 79


    Wow! Your cake is great! Please tell me how you got everything so even and those clean squares?! Amazing!

  42. 82


    Wow, cool pic of you and Dorie!

    I love what you have done with the recipe, the cakes are gorgeous!

  43. 83


    Awwww I love the picture with you and Dorie.. is simply fantastic, it just made me feel so special to be part of the Daring Bakers!!! Your cake looks beautiful congratulations on your challenge!!!

  44. 86


    Great stuff as usual! I can’t wait to trade notes about my trip to San Francisco (Where I visited Ubuntu). I guess I never knew what a foodie city SF was. How ignorant of me! Anyway, looking forward to your write up from New York.

  45. 87


    What a neat picture! Your cake slices are SO CUTE! I love the perfect little square. Great job.

  46. 88


    Happy Happy everything Anita!
    So sorry I missed you in New York.
    Darn ole Paris plans could not be changed. But it looks like you had a swell time!

  47. 89


    u a hve cool blog ..plz add me in ur favorite…
    if u r intersested.. add me in ur blogg… an msg me in me blog.. ill too add u…

  48. 92


    welcome back! as always your dessert look very pristine :) what an honor to see Dorie in person!

  49. 94

    Rachel says

    Hi, I’m a long time lurker and just felt I should say; I love your blog! It’s one of my favourites and has an automatic place on the check-everytime-I-go-online-for-updates list. Apart from the obvious (yummy food, beautiful photography etc) your language is brilliant. I know this sounds wierd, but one of the things that turns me off a blog is annoying language. Anyway yours is beautifully fresh and delicious and literate. Well done, and keep it coming.

  50. 96


    So sorry I am just getting to this now – what perfect pieces! Makes me wish I had more of the cake to eat…right now! :)

  51. 97



    I have enjoyed your blog (secretly) for a while. I wanted to thank you for your excellent work by passing on a nomination for “E is for Excellent”.

    Great work! Thank you,


  52. 99

    Cecilia says

    Hi Anita,

    Wow!! This was a cinch to make! It’s so light and fluffy. What a lovely cake. :) And you got to hang out with Dorie!! How cool is that!

  53. 100

    Jenny Ho says

    Hey Anita!

    This cake looks absolutely delicious!! I really want to bake this cake for my friend’s birthday, but she has a medical condition that won’t allow her to have any refined sugars. Are there any substitutions I can make while still keeping the flavors of the cake?

  54. 101

    Janice says

    Hi. I tried the recipe for this cake and I thought it came out too sweet. The top of the cake was slightly crunchy after I took it out as the sugar had created a little crust.

  55. 102

    Jessica says

    haha, this is about 3 years late I suppose, but I made this cake last week and it was really awesome. it’s my new favorite cake :) thanks! i really enjoy reading your blog!

  56. 103

    Angelique says

    Hi Anita, i am daring myself to bake this gorgeous cake. Please tell me what size of pan should I use ?
    Love your blog,

    • 104

      Anita says

      Hi Angelique, you can use two 9-in round cake pans. I think that’s what the recipe says. Happy baking!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>